Microsoft EA Renewal Playbook for CIOs and Procurement Leaders

Microsoft EA Renewal Playbook for CIOs and Procurement Leaders

Microsoft Enterprise Agreement renewals require strategic planning and savvy negotiation.

This playbook provides a step-by-step framework for CIOs and procurement leaders to manage an EA renewal from start to finish, ensuring optimized costs and alignment with business needs.

By following these best practices, large enterprises can secure more value in their Microsoft contracts while mitigating compliance risks and avoiding common pitfalls.

Read how to negotiate your Microsoft EA.

Step 1: Start Planning Early and Assemble Your Team

Renewal success begins well before the contract end date. Treat the EA renewal as a major project, not a last-minute task.

• Timeline: Kick off internal planning 12 to 18 months before your EA expires (at minimum, 8–12 months prior). This gives you a generous runway for analysis and strategy.
• Assemble stakeholders: Form a cross-functional working group for the renewal. Include IT architects, software asset managers (SAM/ITAM), procurement specialists, finance, and representatives from key business units. Early stakeholder alignment ensures all requirements and concerns are heard.
• Set objectives: Define clear goals for the renewal upfront. For example, you might aim to reduce overall spending by 10% or add a new product (like Power Platform or Azure services) within the current budget. Establishing targets and success criteria will guide your negotiation strategy and internal decision-making.
• Executive sponsorship: Secure support from a C-level sponsor (CIO or CFO). High-level backing empowers the negotiation team to hold firm on important issues and signals to Microsoft that your company is serious about getting a fair deal. A unified, executive-supported team prevents Microsoft’s sales tactics from exploiting internal divides (such as pitting IT needs against finance constraints).

Read Top Microsoft EA Negotiation Mistakes and How to Avoid Them.

Step 2: Audit Current Usage and Forecast Future Needs

Before engaging with Microsoft, gather data on your current environment and anticipate your needs in the next term.

• Inventory your licenses: Conduct a thorough internal audit of your current Microsoft licenses and subscriptions. This means creating an Effective License Position (ELP) – a detailed comparison of licenses owned versus licenses deployed/used. Identify any gaps (under-licensing) or surpluses (over-licensing).
• Analyze usage patterns: Look at how each product is being utilized. Which applications are mission-critical and widely used? Which are underused or could be phased out? For instance, maybe you deployed 1,000 Visio licenses but find only 300 active users. Such insights highlight opportunities to cut or downgrade licenses at renewal.
• Check compliance: Verify that you’ve been following the rules. Ensure all user counts and deployments have been properly reported in past annual True-Ups. If you discover any compliance issues (e.g., more users using Office 365 than you paid for), plan to address them now. It’s far better to proactively true-up and include those licenses in your renewal proposal than to be caught in an audit later.
• Forecast 3–5 years out: Work with business units to project changes in headcount, new projects, or technology initiatives that will drive Microsoft license needs. Are you expecting significant growth or divestitures? Planning a move to more cloud services? For example, if a division plans to adopt Dynamics 365 in year 2, account for that in the renewal strategy. Conversely, you may need fewer SQL Server licenses if you expect to retire some on-premise systems. A forward-looking demand plan helps you negotiate the right products and quantities (and avoids overcommitting “just in case”).

Step 3: Optimize and Right-Size Your License Portfolio

With current and future needs in hand, identify optimization opportunities before locking in another three-year agreement.

• Eliminate shelfware: Create a list of licenses that can be dropped or reduced based on your usage audit. Typical targets include unused Office 365 seats, rarely accessed services like Project or Visio, or redundant solutions (e.g., multiple Microsoft security products where one would suffice). Plan to true-down these quantities at renewal so you aren’t paying for idle software. Many companies find 10–20% of their licenses are shelfware that can be cut, yielding immediate savings.
• Right-size license levels: Evaluate if all users have the appropriate software edition. It’s common to find instances of over-provisioning, such as all employees on an E5 plan when perhaps only a subset needs those advanced features. Segment your user base into profiles (e.g., power vs. basic users, or knowledge workers vs. occasional users). You might downgrade some to E3 or E1, or move certain workloads to cheaper SKUs. Example: One enterprise realized most of their staff never used the voice and analytics features of Office 365 E5, so they planned to renew 70% of users on E3 and only 30% on E5, significantly cutting costs while delivering the right capabilities to each group.
• Consider license substitutions: Examine if newer Microsoft offerings could replace older ones more cost-effectively. For instance, if you have separate Skype for Business and older Office licenses, consolidating into Microsoft 365 could be more efficient. Or if you maintain on-prem server licenses with Software Assurance, evaluate if shifting to equivalent Azure services or subscriptions at renewal might reduce total cost.
• Document changes: Create a detailed optimization plan listing which licenses to drop, reduce, or change. This becomes a key input to requesting Microsoft’s renewal quote (so they quote only what you truly need). It also serves as evidence during negotiations, showing Microsoft you have done your homework on what you will and won’t purchase.

Step 4: Understand EA Pricing and Discount Programs

Knowledge is power in pricing. Ensure you understand how Microsoft’s volume licensing pricing works and where you fit.

• Volume tiers: Microsoft EAs have built-in volume discount levels (A, B, C, D) based on the number of users or devices. Larger organizations automatically get better pricing. Know your level and how close you are to the next tier.

Larger seat counts generally yield deeper automatic discounts. Microsoft has even signaled plans to phase out smaller EAs under 2,400 users, steering those customers to other channels. Due to their scale, Level C or D enterprises have strong negotiating clout.

• Current price lists and increases: Research Microsoft’s pricing trends for the products you use. Have there been recent list price increases (for example, Microsoft 365 went up in 2022)? Remember that your renewal will be priced at the latest rates unless you negotiate otherwise. Also, account for any announced price changes or foreign exchange rate impacts that could hit at renewal.
• Benchmark discounts: If possible, obtain benchmark data on what discounts similar companies (size or industry) have achieved. For instance, know the typical discount percentage for an Office 365 E5 or Azure consumption in a deal of your volume. While such information can be hard to get, even a rough range (say 15–25% off list for a large enterprise deal) gives you a target.
• Microsoft’s fiscal calendar: Recognize that negotiating affects pricing flexibility. Microsoft sales reps have quotas and get more aggressive with discounts at fiscal year-end (June) or sometimes the end of the calendar year. Plan your negotiation timeline (in Step 5) to leverage this, but never assume timing guarantees a good deal—you must still push on the numbers.

Step 5: Develop a Negotiation Strategy and Set Your Targets

Approach the negotiation with a clear game plan. This is not just about haggling on unit prices – it’s a strategic exercise in securing value.

• Prioritize your must-haves: From all your preparation, pinpoint the most important items for your organization. Is it a certain budget cap? A new product included? Flexibility in terms (like the ability to reduce licenses if the business shrinks)? List these out as non-negotiables or high priorities. Also, identify what’s less important and can be used as bargaining chips.
• Explore alternatives and competitive options: Even if you intend to stick with Microsoft, investigate alternatives to strengthen your position. For example, get a quote from a Cloud Solution Provider (CSP) for comparable subscriptions – CSPs sometimes offer more flexible terms or slight savings. Or evaluate if a subset of users could use Google Workspace or AWS for certain services. You might not switch, but being prepared to present alternatives gives you leverage. Microsoft will realize they need to earn your renewal, not just assume it.
• Engage in pre-negotiation dialogue: Sign what you are looking for to your Microsoft account manager (and/or reseller) early. Share your projected needs and ask for initial pricing proposals 6+ months out. This early quote serves as a baseline and helps identify gaps. It also tells Microsoft you expect a custom deal (not just a standard renewal).
• Use Microsoft’s incentives to your advantage: Microsoft is keenly interested in certain product adoption (currently, Azure, security & compliance add-ons, Dynamics 365, and Microsoft 365 E5 upgrades). If some of these align with your plans, include them in the negotiation as tradeable items. For example, “We’re considering moving more workloads to Azure over the next 3 years. In exchange, we need better unit pricing and some Azure credits.” Aligning your asks with Microsoft’s strategic priorities can unlock extra incentives (like discounted Azure consumption rates or free trials for new services).
• Set a walk-away plan: In rare cases, if the negotiation isn’t meeting critical goals, you should have a Plan B. This could be extending the existing agreement briefly (if allowable) or pausing certain projects. While most renewals will conclude with Microsoft, knowing you could survive without immediately signing gives you confidence. (For example, some organizations prepare to move a portion of workloads to month-to-month subscriptions as a fallback to avoid being forced into a bad deal under time pressure.)

Step 6: Execute the Negotiation with Microsoft

Now it’s time to engage formally and work through proposals and counter-proposals. This phase is where all your preparation pays off through disciplined negotiation tactics.

• Budget and proposal breakdown: When Microsoft presents a renewal quote, dissect it thoroughly. Break down the costs by component: How much for Office 365, Windows, Azure, etc. Scrutinize each line item’s quantity and unit price against your expectations. It’s common to find misalignments – perhaps Microsoft quoted more licenses than you need “to be safe,” or included a premium bundle where a standard one suffices. Identify these and prepare specific counters (e.g., “We only need 800 E5 licenses, not 1,000 as quoted”).
• Negotiate methodically: Expect multiple rounds of negotiation. Start with the big-ticket items – overall cost, major product bundles, discount percentages. Communicate where the quote falls short: “This proposal is 15% over our budget – we need to find reductions.” Use your data: “Our analysis shows we only use X licenses, so we will not pay for Y as quoted.” Provide Microsoft with a revised demand set or an itemized counter-proposal. It can help to put this in writing so nothing is misunderstood.
• Leverage timing and Microsoft’s quarter: As you negotiate, remember the calendar. If you’re in Microsoft’s Q4 (April–June for them) and the deal isn’t where you need it, you might slow down talks to let the pressure build on their side. Conversely, if you’re negotiating earlier, you might say, “We have time, and we’re evaluating other options; we’ll revisit this in a couple of months,” which signals you won’t be rushed. When the end of the quarter arrives, Microsoft may return with an improved offer rather than lose the deal.
• Maintain a united front: During negotiations, ensure all communication to Microsoft flows through your core team and everyone is on the same page internally. Microsoft reps might try the classic “divide and conquer,” reaching out to separate stakeholders to gather information or create urgency. Avoid side conversations that aren’t part of the main negotiation strategy. For example, suppose the Microsoft salesperson calls an IT manager asking what it would take to close this week. In that case, that person should redirect them to the procurement lead and reaffirm the need to meet the organization’s defined requirements.
• Document everything: Keep a log of promises or special offers Microsoft makes during calls or meetings. If the rep says, “We can probably approve a 20% discount on that product” or “We’ll include 100 hours of consulting services at no charge,” write it down and later get it in writing via email. Cross-check the formal paperwork (the EA renewal order, amendment letters, etc.) against your notes to ensure every concession is captured as you converge on a final deal. Do not rely on verbal assurances – only the written contract counts once signed.

Step 7: Finalize the Contract and Plan for Ongoing Management

Closing the deal correctly is as important as negotiating it. Once you have a negotiated agreement with Microsoft, you must lock it in and set yourself up for success in the new term.

• Legal and commercial review: Have your procurement and legal teams review the final EA documents line by line. Ensure that pricing reflects what was agreed upon (every discount is applied correctly) and that any special terms, like the ability to swap certain licenses or extended timelines for a cloud transition, are explicitly included in the contract. If something discussed isn’t in writing, now is the time to speak up. It’s much harder to fix mistakes after the signature.
• Don’t rush signing: While there may be pressure to sign (especially if you extended negotiations to a quarter-end), take the time needed to verify details. A common safeguard is to prepare an internal sign-off checklist of all negotiated points to verify against the contract. Double-check quantities, renewal options, payment schedules, and support provisions.
• True-up and baseline reset: Immediately after renewal, establish the new “baseline” of licenses with your SAM team. Clear out old records and start tracking usage against the new agreement from day one. This will make future true-up cycles smoother. Communicate the new license entitlements to IT teams so they can deploy software aligned with what’s purchased.
• Post-renewal adoption plan: Work with business units to drive adoption of any new tools or services included in the EA. For example, if you added Power Apps or an upgraded security suite, ensure that training is provided and those tools are used. The goal is to realize the value of everything you’re paying for. This benefits your operations and positions you strongly for the next renewal (you can decide based on real usage what to keep or drop).
• Ongoing vendor management: The Microsoft relationship will be managed actively throughout the EA term. Hold regular check-ins with your Microsoft account team to stay informed about product changes or new offers. Keep your stakeholder team alive to monitor usage and compliance annually. An EA is a living contract – by treating it as an ongoing process rather than a one-time event, you’ll avoid surprises and be well prepared when the next renewal cycle comes around.

Recommendations

• Begin preparations 1 year in advance: Early planning is vital. Establish your renewal team and start collecting requirements at least 12 months out to avoid rushing and ensure all options are evaluated.
• Audit and cleanup before renewing: Perform a thorough license and usage audit. Resolve any compliance gaps and drop what you don’t need. It’s far cheaper to optimize now than to carry redundant licenses into a new 3-year term.
• Define your negotiation goals: Enter negotiations with clear objectives (cost savings targets, products to add or cut, needed contract terms). A well-defined strategy keeps discussions focused and productive.
• Leverage your size and alternatives: Use your volume (EA tier) and any viable alternatives as bargaining chips. Remind Microsoft of your significance as a customer and that you have choices to extract better discounts and terms.
• Time the negotiation wisely: Whenever possible, align deal closure with Microsoft’s end-of-quarter or fiscal year to maximize their incentive to discount. However, always leave a safety margin before expiration to finalize paperwork.
• Negotiate beyond just price: Pay attention to contract details like true-up rules, price locks, and flexibility to adjust licenses. Negotiating these terms can save money and headaches later, just as much as a big discount can.
• Verify the final contract: Before signing, double-check that every agreed concession (price, credits, terms) is captured in writing. Don’t assume – ensure the contract language matches your understanding to prevent future disputes.
• Drive adoption post-renewal: Once the deal is signed, execute on user training and system rollouts for any new software gained. Monitor usage from day one. Adopting paid features will maximize ROI and inform better decisions at the next renewal.

FAQ

Q1: How far in advance should a CIO start the EA renewal process?
A1: Ideally, 12 months or more before the EA expiration. Large enterprises benefit from starting even 18 months out. This lead time is used to audit usage, plan needs, and engage in preliminary talks. Starting early means you won’t be forced into a corner as the deadline nears.

Q2: What if our company size changes before the new EA? How would we handle that?
A2: Use the planning phase to forecast changes. If you expect significant growth or reduction in users, incorporate that into your renewal quantities. Microsoft’s volume pricing tier is based on your initial purchase count, so aim to size it right. If uncertain, lean slightly conservative (you can always add via True-Up). Also, negotiate terms for flexibility if possible (for example, rights to reduce or transition licenses if a divestiture happens).

Q3: Is it possible to reduce the number of licenses in the middle of an EA term?
A3: Not typically. Under standard EA rules, you can increase license counts annually (True-Up) but cannot reduce commitments until the next renewal. That’s why it’s crucial to only commit to what you need. Some very large customers negotiate special terms for mid-term adjustments or have the option to shift to cloud subscriptions, but those are exceptions. Plan your quantities carefully at renewal since you’ll be locked in for three years.

Q4: How can we negotiate a better Microsoft 365 or Azure discount?
A4: Preparation and leverage. Come with data – for instance, show your current spend and usage efficiency to justify a discount (“we’re using Azure efficiently, so to expand further, we need a better rate”). Use competitive bids (like AWS estimates or Google Workspace pricing) to pressure Microsoft. Also, consider bundling growth commitments: e.g., if you commit to move a workload to Azure, ask for an extra Azure consumption discount or credits in return. Ultimately, get multiple quote iterations and don’t be shy to counteroffer – Microsoft expects it.

Q5: Should we consider the Cloud Solution Provider (CSP) program instead of an EA?
A5: For some organizations, yes. CSP is a more flexible month-to-month subscription model, often through a partner. CSP can be attractive if your user count is well below EA’s minimums or if you need a lot of flexibility. However, CSP pricing is usually at or near list price, whereas a large EA can deliver substantial discounts and price locks. Many large enterprises stick with EA for the discounts and enterprise terms, but it’s wise to price out a CSP scenario as a comparison. At the very least, mentioning that you’re evaluating CSP options can be a negotiation lever.

Q6: How do we handle Microsoft pushing new products during renewal?
A6: Evaluate them on merit. Microsoft often pitches new products (security add-ons, Power Platform, etc.) at renewal time. Don’t dismiss them outright; some could benefit your business, but don’t let them derail your core negotiation. If a product is interesting but not in your current plan, you can request a pilot or trial rather than a full EA commitment. Or negotiate a flexible add-on (e.g., the option to add it later at the same discount). Only include new products in the EA if they align with your strategic roadmap and budget.

Q7: What are the key contract terms for an EA renewal?
A7: True-up terms (timing and pricing for adding licenses annually), pricing protection (are your prices fixed for 3 years? What about renewal price caps?), transfer rights (can you move licenses between affiliates or to the cloud), and subscription swap rights (for cloud services, can you transition to newer offerings). Also, review support terms if included, and any compliance/audit clauses. Ensure renewal options are clear some EAs have early renewal or extension clauses. Getting clarity or favorable terms on these can save a lot of cost and risk later.

Q8: How can we mitigate audit risk around the renewal period?
A8: Audits often coincide with renewals. To mitigate this, do an internal audit first (as noted in Step 2). If you find any shortfall (unlicensed use), address it by purchasing what’s needed within the renewal (so you negotiate the best price, rather than paying penalties later). Also, maintain good SAM practices and documentation so you can demonstrate compliance. Some companies negotiate audit terms or even audit relief for the new term, although Microsoft may not always agree. The best defense is to enter renewal knowing your compliance position cold.

Q9: Our Microsoft rep says we must include certain products enterprise-wide due to policy – is that negotiable?
A9: Microsoft’s EA program does have requirements (for example, if you license Office or Windows Enterprise, it’s typically for all “qualified devices/users”). These “enterprise products” need organization-wide coverage to get the EA pricing. However, you can choose not to include a product in your EA if it doesn’t make sense, e.g., if only a subset of users needs Visio, you don’t have to have an enterprise-wide license for Visio; you can buy it separately or just for those users. Be mindful of what products you designate as enterprise-wide in the EA. If Microsoft is pushing something like an E5 security bundle for all, but you only need it for 100 users, push back and carve that out as a separate component or outside the EA.

Q10: What should we do immediately after signing the renewal?
A10: Right after signing, conduct a post-mortem and rollout plan. Gather your team and document what went well and lessons learned for next time (building internal knowledge). Ensure all new licenses are properly allocated in your asset management system. Communicate the new contract details to all stakeholders, IT ops, finance (for budgeting the annual payments), and helpdesk or software request teams (so they know what’s covered). Finally, kick off any adoption initiatives for new services acquired. By proactively managing the new EA from day one, you’ll get maximum value and stay in control throughout the term.

Read about our Microsoft Negotiation Services.

Do you want to know more about our Microsoft Negotiation Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit