Microsoft EA Renewal Strategy: What to Review Before You Sign Again

Microsoft EA Renewal Strategy: What to Review Before You Sign Again

Executive Summary: Renewing a Microsoft Enterprise Agreement (EA) is critical for any large organization.

This guide outlines the key areas to review before signing your EA renewal. It focuses on data preparation, usage analysis, and building a strong business justification to ensure your next EA delivers maximum value and aligns with your company’s needs.

Read about Microsoft EA Renewal Strategies.

Gather and Analyze Your Licensing Data

Before entering renewal negotiations, deep dive into your current license inventory and usage.

Data preparation is essential:

• Inventory All Licenses: Compile a detailed list of all software and services under your existing EA, including quantities and license types.
• Usage Metrics: Review actual consumption for each product. Identify how many licenses are actively used versus sitting idle. Use admin portals or asset management tools to pinpoint inactive accounts and underutilized applications.
• True-Up History: Examine your true-up records over the past term. Note where you consistently added licenses (growth areas) and where licenses remained unused. These trends will guide how you adjust quantities for the new term.

EA Renewal Review Data Checklist

Having solid, factual data on your current deployment arms you with leverage. It highlights discrepancies between what you’re paying for and what you use, forming the foundation for an informed renewal strategy.

Read How to Right-Size Your Microsoft EA Before Renewal.

Identify Underutilized and Unneeded Licenses

A core part of your usage review is pinpointing licenses and services that are not fully utilized:

• Unused Licenses: Flag licenses assigned to departed employees or unused projects. Plan to eliminate or reassign these instead of paying for them again.
• Underutilized Upgrades: Check if premium licenses are truly needed. If you bought Microsoft 365 E5 for advanced features but few users use them, downgrading those users to E3 can significantly cut costs.
• Redundant Tools: Look for overlap. You might be paying for third-party solutions that duplicate your Microsoft subscriptions’ capabilities. Eliminating those redundancies allows you to remove related Microsoft licenses or avoid upgrading to costlier plans.

By cutting out excess, you right-size the EA to what’s needed. This saves money and simplifies compliance. Microsoft may push back on reductions since they impact their revenue, so be ready to show the data behind each change. Reallocating licenses or dropping unused ones frees up budget for new priorities without raising overall spending.

Align the EA with Future Business Needs

Your EA renewal should reflect your organization’s evolving strategy. Ensure the new agreement aligns with upcoming needs:

• Technology Roadmap: Review your IT plans for the next 3–5 years. If you’re migrating to cloud services, adopting new tools (Power Platform, Dynamics 365, etc.), or standardizing on certain technologies, make sure the renewal’s products and counts support those initiatives.
• Workforce Changes: Factor in expected expansion, contraction, or acquisitions. If you anticipate major shifts in headcount, consider an Enterprise Subscription Agreement instead of a traditional EA. This allows annual license reductions (true-downs) if your user base shrinks, adding flexibility at the cost of giving up perpetual license rights.
• Updated Licensing Options: Stay informed about Microsoft’s latest bundles and licensing programs. New license types (like Microsoft 365 F3 for frontline workers) or changes in bundles might better suit some users at a lower cost. Ensure you’re not renewing any component that no longer provides value or has a more efficient alternative.

Aligning the EA with business objectives turns the renewal into a strategic tool. Build flexibility for uncertain needs (e.g., negotiate the option to add a new product later at locked pricing) so you aren’t forced to overspend or miss out on future capabilities.

Build a Solid Business Justification

CIOs and procurement leaders must often justify the EA renewal to finance and executives.

A strong business case will cover:

• Cost vs. Value: Outline the annual and three-year costs of the EA and what the organization gets in return. Break down costs by major area – e.g., “Microsoft 365 E3 for 2,000 users costs $X per year, delivering email, collaboration, and security tools to the entire company.” Highlight any savings from retiring redundant systems or consolidating vendors under this EA.
• ROI and Benefits: Explain expected gains. If you plan to upgrade some users or add services, describe the benefits (better security, productivity, compliance) and why they justify the expense. Use metrics where possible, like “consolidating onto Teams will save $Y currently spent on other meeting software.”
• Risk Mitigation: Emphasize risks avoided by a well-structured renewal. For example, continuing Software Assurance avoids hefty upgrade fees and ensures support. Locking in pricing for three years protects against sudden price hikes and enables budgeting with confidence.
• Negotiated Savings: Show that you’re driving a hard bargain. If your analysis found 15% of licenses were excess, note that you’re cutting that waste (saving $Z) and have negotiated lower pricing or credits based on those cuts. Demonstrating due diligence and optimization efforts assures executives that no money is being left on the table.

You turn a hefty expense into a strategic investment by framing the renewal as a value-driven decision. Share this business case with senior leadership early to secure buy-in before final negotiations with Microsoft.

Recommendations

• Start Early: Kick off your EA renewal project 6–12 months before expiration to allow ample time for analysis, internal discussion, and negotiations.
• Audit and Clean House: Thoroughly audit current license usage. Remove or reassign inactive user licenses and eliminate any software that isn’t being used, so you only renew what’s necessary.
• Right-Size License Levels: Match users with appropriate license tiers. Don’t pay for high-end E5 licenses for users who only need E3 or lower; leverage cheaper Frontline plans for occasional-use or kiosk workers to cut costs.
• Leverage Your Data: Bring your usage data to the negotiating table. Use it to push for better pricing or to justify dropping certain products. Showing Microsoft you have a clear picture of needs puts you in control of the conversation.
• Align with Strategy: Ensure the renewed EA supports your upcoming projects and strategic initiatives. Exclude components that don’t align with your roadmap, and seek flexibility (like the option to add new products later at locked pricing).
• Consider Flex Agreement: If you expect major changes in headcount, consider an Enterprise Subscription EA, which allows annual true-downs. This can prevent overpaying for licenses you might not use if your organization contracts.
• Secure Executive Buy-In: Present a concise business case to executives highlighting costs, benefits, and optimizations. Getting CFO and stakeholder approval early will make final sign-off a formality rather than a hurdle.
• Review Contract Terms: Before signing, double-check all terms. Ensure any negotiated discounts, price protections, and special conditions (like pilot programs or product swap rights) are documented in the agreement.

FAQ

Q1: What’s the biggest mistake companies make in EA renewals?
A1: Often it’s going on autopilot – renewing the same agreement without scrutinizing it. This leads to paying for licenses that aren’t used or missing the chance to incorporate newer, better-suited options. Every renewal should be approached as a fresh contract, not just an extension of the old one.

Q2: How far in advance should we start preparing for an EA renewal?
A2: Start about 6 to 12 months before your EA expires. Early preparation gives you time to assess usage, consult all business units for future needs, set budget expectations, and engage Microsoft in meaningful negotiations. Rushing this process can leave savings on the table.

Q3: How can we tell if we are underutilizing certain licenses or services?
A3: Leverage the usage reports in Microsoft 365 and Azure admin portals (or your SAM tools). They show which users are active on which services and which features are used. For instance, if only 10% of users with an E5 license use the E5-exclusive features, that’s a clear sign of over-licensing those users. Similarly, Azure resources can be monitored for low utilization. These insights point directly to where you can trim or downgrade.

Q4: Our company has grown since the last EA – won’t we pay more?
A4: Growth doesn’t have to mean a proportional cost spike. Identify where you’ve expanded and right-size those additions (new users might only need E3 instead of E5, for example). Use your larger volume as leverage to negotiate better discounts so your per-user cost stays in check.

Q5: How do I convince the CFO to renew the EA?
A5: Translate the renewal into business value. Explain what this spend will enable (e.g., equipping all employees with modern productivity and security tools). Highlight that you’ve cut out waste and secured discounts to keep costs lean. Emphasize the risks of not renewing, such as paying more for piecemeal licenses or facing security gaps on unsupported software, so the renewal is considered a smart, necessary investment.

Q6: Is an Enterprise Agreement always the best choice?
A6: It depends on your scale and plans. For a large organization that relies heavily on Microsoft software, an EA often gives the best value. Suppose you’re smaller or expect to scale down usage. In that case, alternatives like CSP (monthly subscriptions) or an Enterprise Subscription EA can offer more flexibility, but possibly at higher per-license costs or without the benefit of owning the licenses outright. Weigh the trade-offs of flexibility versus cost for your situation.

Q7: What’s the benefit of an Enterprise Subscription EA?
A7: An Enterprise Subscription lets you reduce license counts annually if needs drop, offering flexibility that a standard EA lacks. This is great for organizations that might shrink or reorganize during the term. The trade-off is that you don’t own the licenses at the end (so you must renew or stop using the software). Essentially, you pay for flexibility, which can be worth it if you foresee significant changes.

Q8: How can we negotiate a better EA deal?
A8: Go in with a clear plan and data on your side. Show Microsoft that you intend to remove unused services, which signals you won’t pay for shelfware. Be explicit about what you want: deeper discounts, price caps, deployment credits, and justify your requests. If you hit resistance, escalate to Microsoft executives. The first offer is just a starting point; you can often improve the terms with persistence and data.

Q9: What if we end up with too many licenses after renewal?
A9: You can’t drop licenses mid-term in a standard EA – you’re stuck with them until the next renewal. If you over-purchase, make the best of it by deploying those extra licenses in new projects or to more users so they’re not wasted. It’s a lesson to carry into the next cycle: negotiate shorter terms or a subscription model for areas of uncertainty. You can also talk to Microsoft to see if any mid-term adjustments are possible, but typically, they’re not obligated once the contract is in place.

Q10: How do our international operations affect the EA?
A10: Regional factors like currency and local pricing can impact your costs. Microsoft may adjust foreign pricing if exchange rates shift significantly. To avoid surprises, you can negotiate to lock in pricing in one currency or cap these adjustments. Also, in your contract, account for any region-specific needs (such as EU data residency rules). In short, factor in your global footprint so the EA terms work for all your key regions.

Read about our Microsoft Negotiation Services.

Do you want to know more about our Microsoft Negotiation Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit