Reading the Fine Print: Don’t Let Microsoft’s Assurances Hide Contract Gotchas

Reading the Fine Print: Don’t Let Microsoft’s Assurances Hide Contract Gotchas

Introduction – Why the Fine Print Matters

Microsoft Enterprise Agreements (EAs) can exceed 100 pages of dense legal and licensing jargon. It’s tempting to assume all that boilerplate is harmless standard text, and many procurement teams end up skimming over the minutiae.

That’s a costly mistake. Hidden in the fine print of a Microsoft EA are clauses that quietly shift risk or future costs onto your organization.

The reality is that Microsoft’s contracts are drafted to protect Microsoft’s interests first and foremost.

If buyers don’t scrutinize every line, they can inadvertently agree to terms that undermine the deal they believe they negotiated. CIOs and CFOs may discover unpleasant surprises down the road – like a verbal promise from a sales rep that wasn’t actually written into the EA, or a “standard” clause that negated a key pricing protection.

In a multi-million dollar, multi-year agreement, the contract isn’t just legal fluff – it’s where your risks and obligations truly live.

Paying attention to those details is essential to avoid future headaches. For a full overview of what pitfalls to watch out for, read our guide to Avoiding Common Microsoft EA Renewal Pitfalls.

Common Fine-Print Gotchas in Microsoft EAs

While every contract is unique, certain hidden clauses show up frequently in Microsoft EAs. These are known pitfalls that have caught many enterprises off guard.

Here are some of the most common fine-print gotchas to watch for and why they matter:

Renewal Price Escalators

One big hidden risk is what happens to your pricing at renewal time. Microsoft often raises its price lists by around 5–10% annually. If your EA doesn’t explicitly protect your renewal pricing, expect those increases to hit you.

In other words, when your initial term ends, the cost for the same licenses could jump significantly because the contract defaults to “then-current rates” (the list price at that future date).

We’ve seen customers shocked by renewal quotes 20% higher for the same products simply because they lacked a price cap in their agreement. Some contracts even bake in automatic year-over-year escalations unless you negotiate them out.

The result is a budget surprise and a lot of post-renewal regret.

To avoid this, consider negotiating multi-year price locks or, at the very least, a cap on increases at renewal. If it isn’t clearly spelled out in writing, assume your costs will rise.

Usage Rights Changes

Another fine-print trick involves Microsoft’s ability to change product usage terms during the contract period. Many EAs incorporate Microsoft’s Product Terms or Online Services Terms by reference – meaning you agree to abide by whatever rules Microsoft publishes, even if they update those rules over time.

The risk here is that features and rights you had at signing might not remain available under the same conditions.

For example, a feature included in your software edition today could be moved to a higher-tier license or an add-on tomorrow through a policy change. Suddenly, a capability your users rely on would require an upgrade or extra purchase.

This scenario isn’t hypothetical – Microsoft has reclassified features into more expensive editions mid-contract before.

Unless you negotiated an amendment to freeze key usage terms at the start, you’re vulnerable to these shifts. It can feel like a bait-and-switch: you thought you bought one thing, but the fine print lets Microsoft alter what you actually get.

Make sure you negotiate flexibility with Microsoft. Trapped in Your Microsoft EA? How to Ensure Flexibility and Avoid Lock-In.

Indirect Access & Dual Use Rights

Microsoft’s licensing rules don’t just apply to direct users – they can also apply to indirect use. If any user or system indirectly accesses a Microsoft product, you might need extra licenses.

For example, if a third-party application or an automated script pulls data from a SQL Server, Microsoft may insist that those users or devices have their own CALs.

Many companies only learn about this after an audit, when Microsoft presents a bill for “unlicensed” indirect users that were never accounted for.

Dual-use rights are meant to allow you to use both an on-premises version and its cloud counterpart (or run an older software version alongside a newer one), but often there are strings attached.

Typically, you must maintain active Software Assurance or meet specific conditions to enjoy dual-use rights.

If you assumed you could use your software freely in multiple environments, a buried clause might say otherwise unless you’ve kept up certain coverage.

If you have integration-heavy or hybrid scenarios, clarify those usage rights in your EA upfront.

Limited-Time Discounts

Microsoft often offers enticing upfront discounts in an EA, but the fine print might limit how long those savings last. A common gotcha is that the discount only applies to the initial term. After that, prices may revert to the full list unless you negotiated otherwise. This creates a price “cliff” at renewal.

For example, a 30% discount during a three-year term will disappear in year four if not contractually extended, immediately raising your costs by that 30%.

In some agreements, the discount even erodes a bit each year of the term (say, 15% in year 1, 10% in year 2, 5% in year 3) so that you’re already paying near full price by the end.

Whether the drop is sudden or gradual, it’s a shock if you aren’t expecting it. To avoid this, negotiate renewal price protections. That could mean carrying the same discount into the renewal, or at least capping any price increase so you don’t get blindsided by a major uptick.

Auto-Enrollments & Program Shifts

Microsoft sometimes slips in clauses that commit you to future actions without explicit consent.

For example, your EA might say that at renewal you will “enter into Microsoft’s then-current agreement” – meaning Microsoft can move you to a new licensing program (like the Microsoft Customer Agreement) when your term ends.

This could strip away discounts or flexibility you had under the EA. Likewise, be wary of any requirement that you “maintain Software Assurance” or similar coverage throughout the term (or beyond) just to keep certain rights.

Clauses like these can force you into paying for things longer than intended or switching to an unwanted model to avoid losing benefits. Always identify these hidden obligations and push to remove or modify them.

You should have the freedom to decide your licensing path at renewal – not be automatically enrolled in whatever program Microsoft prefers.

Why Trusting Assurances Isn’t Enough

Microsoft’s reps often provide plenty of verbal reassurances during negotiations: “Don’t worry about that clause, we never enforce it,” or “Your discounts will remain stable,” and so on.

These promises might be sincere in the moment, but they mean nothing once the contract is signed. If it isn’t written in the EA, it isn’t guaranteed. Many customers have learned this the hard way.

For example, a CIO believed a sales manager’s promise that their 20% discount would carry into the renewal, only to discover that the signed EA limited that discount to the first three-year term.

At renewal, Microsoft quoted full list prices – completely in line with the contract, even if it felt like a broken promise. The takeaway is clear: never rely on informal assurances or handshake deals.

Every significant promise or understanding must be documented in the contract or an addendum. Otherwise, you should assume it won’t be honored.

In the end, a friendly relationship with Microsoft is nice, but a solid written agreement is what will actually protect you.

How to Verify and Protect Yourself

Facing Microsoft’s fine print may feel daunting, but there are practical steps to ensure you’re truly getting the deal you think you are.

Here’s how to verify that your negotiated terms are properly captured and guard against hidden surprises:

• Cross-Check Negotiated Terms: Ensure every concession you negotiated (discounts, special terms, etc.) appears clearly in the EA. If anything is missing or unclear, get it fixed in writing before signing.
• Scrutinize Renewal Clauses: Examine the contract’s renewal wording. If it says pricing will be at “then-current rates,” negotiate a change – remove it or at least cap the increase. Don’t leave renewal costs open-ended.
• Clarify External References: If the EA points to outside documents (Product Terms, Online Services terms, etc.), ask whether those are fixed as of signing or update automatically. Push to freeze those terms. If they can change, be sure to monitor updates.
• Spot Red Flags: Be alert for wording like “must maintain X” or “at Microsoft’s discretion.” These phrases often hide one-sided obligations or loopholes. Negotiate these clauses – remove them or make the terms mutual – so you don’t unknowingly agree to something unfair.
• Bring in an Expert: Consider having a Microsoft licensing specialist or experienced attorney review the final draft. They can spot hidden risks or ambiguities you might overlook. An expert audit of the fine print can save you from costly surprises.

Fine Print Gotchas vs. Protections

To summarize some common hidden clauses and how to handle them, here’s a quick reference table:

Five Expert Recommendations

1. Never assume Microsoft’s standard clauses are neutral – they’re drafted to favor Microsoft, not you.
2. Make sure every negotiated promise is in the contract – if it’s not in writing, it doesn’t exist.
3. Lock in your renewal pricing – without a written price hold or cap, expect double-digit increases at renewal.
4. Push back on mid-term change clauses – anything that lets Microsoft alter terms (like references to evolving policies) should be questioned or negotiated.
5. Get a licensing expert to review the EA – a specialist can spot hidden “gotchas” and ambiguities that you might miss.

By staying vigilant and not taking any term for granted, you can ensure that Microsoft’s assurances align with the contract you sign. The fine print may be tedious, but it’s where your deal’s true value and risks are determined – so dive into it, ask questions, and don’t hesitate to push for changes. Your future self (and your finance team) will thank you for catching the gotchas before they catch you.

Read about our Microsoft EA Optimization Service.

Do you want to know more about our Microsoft Optimization Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit